Moderate evidence
More
Study of 1,010 therapy patients finds a session-by-session score can flag who may not respond
Study title: The Session-specific Risk Index (SRI) in psychotherapy: Developing longitudinal session-by-session machine learning algorithms to predict the likelihood of non-response to treatment
- Evidence type
- Observational study
- Sample
- n = 1,010
- Sources
- 1 sourcePeer-reviewed
- Published
- 2 min read
- Truvace record
- TRV-2026-3066cite or check it
Study title: The Session-specific Risk Index (SRI) in psychotherapy: Developing longitudinal session-by-session machine learning algorithms to predict the likelihood of non-response to treatment
Researchers built the Session-specific Risk Index (SRI), a score that gives the updated probability that a psychotherapy patient will not respond to treatment. It combines baseline information with clinical data collected in each session. The work used observational records from an outpatient clinic covering 1,010 patients.
Read the study abstract
Introduction This study aimed to develop and introduce an implementation-oriented, session-specific metric called the Session-specific Risk Index (SRI), which defines the likelihood of treatment non-response in psychotherapy. The SRI integrates baseline information with real-time clinical data from each session, providing a continuously updated probability of non-response to treatment. Methods We used observational data from an outpatient clinic, including 1,010 psychotherapy patients. We compared the performanc…
The gain
In an observational study of 1,010 outpatient psychotherapy patients, an elastic net model predicted non-response by session 20 with accuracy of .65-.70 and AUC of .70-.77 across the first ten sessions.
In brief
The team compared elastic net regressions with gradient boosting machines for predicting non-response by session 20. Elastic net models without interaction effects did best over the first ten sessions, with accuracy of .65-.70 and AUC rising from .70 to .77.
The authors say that if clinics adopt the index, it might improve precision in mental health care beyond models that personalise treatment only from baseline information. The index has not yet been tested in routine clinical practice.
Main points
- The data came from an outpatient clinic and included 1,010 psychotherapy patients.
- Models used initial sociodemographic, diagnostic and clinical information plus the evolution of symptoms across sessions.
- Elastic net regressions and gradient boosting machines were compared for predicting non-response by session 20.
- Elastic net models without interaction effects performed best over the first ten sessions, with accuracy of .65-.70.
- AUC ranged from .70 (95% CI .70-.71) to .77 (.76-.78) over those sessions.
- Maximum Youden indices set thresholds that balance sensitivity and specificity to flag high-risk patients.
- Midpoints of SRI groups correlated with the share of non-responders in each group (weighted correlation .85, 95% CI .83-.86).
The full story
The SRI is designed as an implementation-oriented metric. Instead of a single baseline prediction, it gives a continuously updated probability of non-response as each session adds clinical data.
To build it, the researchers trained elastic net regressions and gradient boosting machines on records from 1,010 outpatients. Inputs were initial sociodemographic, diagnostic and clinical information combined with how patients' symptoms changed over time. The outcome was non-response by session 20.
The best-performing algorithms were used to define the index. Optimal risk thresholds were set using maximum Youden indices to identify high-risk patients. Higher SRI groups had a higher proportion of patients who did not respond, with a weighted correlation of .85.
Sources
1 on file- Psychotherapy and Psychosomaticsdoi:10.1159/pps/aemag026
Talk it over
The Session-specific Risk Index reached AUC of .70 to .77 over the first ten sessions. Is that accuracy enough to change how a therapist treats a patient flagged as high-risk, and what would you want the flag to trigger?
Study of 1,010 therapy patients finds a session-by-session score can flag who may not respondhttps://truvace.com/item/the-session-specific-risk-index-sri-in-psychotherapy-developing-longitudinal-ses
The Session-specific Risk Index reached AUC of .70 to .77 over the first ten sessions. Is that accuracy enough to change how a therapist treats a patient flagged as high-risk, and what would you want the flag to trigger?
Answer in the threadThe data came from one outpatient clinic with 1,010 patients, and the index has not been tested in routine practice. How might results differ for patients or clinics unlike that one?
Answer in the threadIf you were a patient flagged by the index as likely not to respond by session 20, how would you want to be told, and what would you want to happen next?
Answer in the thread
If you have more time
The researchers compared elastic net regressions with gradient boosting machines, and elastic net did best. What would you want to look up about why a simpler model might win here?
Answer in the threadWhat kind of trial, comparing clinics that use the index with clinics that do not, would show whether the score actually improves outcomes for patients?
Answer in the thread
ace
What readers say