Moderate evidence
More
Meta-analysis of 46,071 people finds human-like AI service agents win more trust
Study title: The association between different types of anthropomorphism of artificial intelligence service agents and user trust: A three-level meta-analysis
- Evidence type
- Systematic review or meta-analysis
- Sample
- n = 46,071
- Sources
- 1 sourcePeer-reviewed
- Published
- 2 min read
- Truvace record
- TRV-2026-3062cite or check it
Study title: The association between different types of anthropomorphism of artificial intelligence service agents and user trust: A three-level meta-analysis
A three-level meta-analysis pooled 211 effect sizes from 136 independent samples covering 46,071 people. It found a positive average association between how human-like an AI service agent seems and how much users trust it (r = 0.462, 95% CI 0.420 to 0.502).
Read the study abstract
As artificial intelligence service agents (AISAs) become increasingly widespread, anthropomorphism is often proposed as a way to foster user trust, yet empirical findings remain mixed. Drawing on competing trust-building and trust-undermining mechanisms, we conducted a three-level meta-analysis of 211 effect sizes from 136 independent samples ( N = 46,071) to estimate the anthropomorphism–trust association and examine its boundary conditions. The average association was positive and robust to alternative depende…
The gain
A meta-analysis of 136 independent samples (46,071 people) found that users who saw AI service agents as more human-like reported higher trust in them (r = 0.462), though the link was weaker (r = 0.222) for objectively specified design cues.
In brief
The result is not uniform. The 95% prediction interval runs from -0.131 to 0.811, so in some settings human-like cues were linked to less trust. The association was much weaker for objectively specified design cues (r = 0.222) than for perception-based measures (r = 0.543), most of which captured traits such as competence and warmth.
The authors suggest that human-like cues should complement, rather than replace, demonstrable competence and reliability when AI service agents are designed and deployed.
Main points
- The analysis combined 211 effect sizes from 136 independent samples with 46,071 participants in total.
- The pooled link between anthropomorphism and trust was r = 0.462, and a restricted analysis of global trust, reliance or willingness to depend gave a similar r = 0.475.
- The prediction interval of -0.131 to 0.811 shows the association varied substantially across settings.
- Objectively specified design cues were linked to trust far more weakly (r = 0.222) than perception-based measures (r = 0.543).
- Cognitive and emotional anthropomorphism were more strongly associated with trust than physical anthropomorphism overall, but that gap was no longer significant after adjusting for how it was measured.
- The association was stronger in Eastern than Western samples and in survey than experimental studies; no significant moderation appeared for gender composition or the prespecified service-context categories.
The full story
The researchers drew on competing explanations: that human-like features build trust, and that they can undermine it. They tested these by pooling studies of AI service agents and estimating the anthropomorphism-trust association with a three-level model that accounts for multiple effect sizes from the same sample.
How anthropomorphism was measured mattered. Perception-based measures, most of which captured adjacent trait attributions such as competence and warmth, showed a stronger link (r = 0.543) than objectively specified design cues (r = 0.222). Among design cues, physical and emotional anthropomorphism did not differ significantly, and no design-based cognitive effect sizes were available.
Context also shifted the result: the association was stronger in Eastern than Western samples and in survey than experimental studies. The authors conclude that the pooled figure should not be read as a uniform effect of anthropomorphic design.
Sources
1 on file- Technological Forecasting and Social Changedoi:10.1016/j.techfore.2026.124959
Talk it over
Who gets this benefit, and who was left out of the study or story?
Meta-analysis of 46,071 people finds human-like AI service agents win more trusthttps://truvace.com/item/the-association-between-different-types-of-anthropomorphism-of-artificial-intell
Who gets this benefit, and who was left out of the study or story?
The gain A meta-analysis of 136 independent samples (46,071 people) found that users who saw AI service agents as more human-like reported higher trust in them (r = 0.462), though the link was weaker (r = 0.222) for objectively specified design cues.
Answer in the threadHow do we know? What can this kind of evidence show, and what can’t it?
The evidence This rests on a systematic review or meta-analysis with a sample of 46,071, from Technological Forecasting and Social Change.
Answer in the threadWhat does it leave open? What else would you want to know before acting on it?
The record’s own caveat The authors say construct overlap between anthropomorphism and trust-related outcomes cannot be ruled out, and no design-based cognitive anthropomorphism effect sizes were available, so the pooled association should not be read as a uniform effect of design.
Answer in the threadHave you seen AI used this way where you study, work or live? Did it go the same way?
Answer in the thread
The questions are the same on every record. The details under them are taken from this record as written.
ace


What readers say