70/100

Moderate evidence

Cite
More
EmailLinkedInX

Patients trust doctors less when AI treats them, a 1,574-adult experiment in China finds

Study title: Physician AI disclosure, condition severity, and public trust in digital medicine

Evidence type
Randomized controlled trial
Sample
n = 1,574
Sources
1 sourcePeer-reviewed
Published
2 min read

Study title: Physician AI disclosure, condition severity, and public trust in digital medicine

A randomized experiment in mainland China assigned 1,574 adults to physician profiles that differed by the type of AI use disclosed and by how severe the patient's condition was. Doctors who disclosed administrative AI were rated more favorably than those disclosing diagnostic or therapeutic AI, on both perceptions of the physician and willingness to seek care.

Read the study abstract

Abstract Public trust is central to the implementation of artificial intelligence (AI) in digital medicine, yet little is known about how patients respond to different forms of physician AI disclosure across clinical risk contexts. In a 5 × 2 factorial experiment in mainland China, 1574 adults were randomly assigned to physician profiles varying by AI use type and condition severity. Administrative AI was rated more favorably than diagnostic and therapeutic AI across physician perception and care-seeking intenti…

The problem

In a randomized experiment with 1,574 adults in mainland China, physicians who disclosed diagnostic or therapeutic AI use were rated less favorably than those disclosing administrative AI, and high-severity conditions amplified negative responses to therapeutic AI.

In brief

Severity changed the picture. When the condition was high-severity, people reacted more negatively to therapeutic AI, while an explicit statement that no AI was used was linked to greater willingness to book an appointment. Exploratory analyses suggested competence, trust and empathy accounted for different response patterns.

The authors conclude that AI disclosure should separate administrative from clinical uses and be calibrated to severity. The experiment measured stated intentions rather than real behavior, and the authors call for preregistered replication with behavioral outcomes.

Main points

  1. The study was a 5 × 2 factorial experiment: five types of physician AI use crossed with two levels of condition severity.
  2. 1,574 adults in mainland China were randomly assigned to physician profiles.
  3. Administrative AI was rated more favorably than diagnostic and therapeutic AI on physician perception and care-seeking intention.
  4. High-severity conditions amplified negative responses to therapeutic AI.
  5. Explicit non-AI disclosure was associated with greater appointment willingness under high severity.
  6. Exploratory mediation analyses suggested competence, trust and empathy explained different disclosure-related response patterns.
  7. A supplementary offline community sample in Macao (n = 128) showed directionally consistent main effects.

The full story

Participants in mainland China viewed physician profiles that varied by the kind of AI use disclosed and the severity of the condition. Outcomes included perceptions of the physician and intention to seek care from that doctor.

Administrative AI fared best across outcomes. Diagnostic and therapeutic AI were rated less favorably, and the penalty for therapeutic AI grew when the condition was severe. Under high severity, explicitly saying no AI was used was associated with greater willingness to make an appointment.

Exploratory mediation analyses pointed to competence, trust and empathy as different routes behind the response patterns. A smaller offline sample of 128 people in Macao showed main effects in the same direction.

Sources

1 on file
  1. npj Digital Medicinedoi:10.1038/s41746-026-03484-7
    Peer-reviewed2026-11-19

Talk it over

Four questions to start on
Who carries this cost, and what would have to change to prevent it?

Start with a question

Patients trust doctors less when AI treats them, a 1,574-adult experiment in China findshttps://truvace.com/item/physician-ai-disclosure-condition-severity-and-public-trust-in-digital-medicine

  1. Who carries this cost, and what would have to change to prevent it?

    The problem In a randomized experiment with 1,574 adults in mainland China, physicians who disclosed diagnostic or therapeutic AI use were rated less favorably than those disclosing administrative AI, and high-severity conditions amplified negative responses to therapeutic AI.

    Answer in the thread
  2. How do we know? What can this kind of evidence show, and what can’t it?

    The evidence This rests on a randomized controlled trial with a sample of 1,574, from npj Digital Medicine.

    Answer in the thread
  3. What does it leave open? What else would you want to know before acting on it?

    The record’s own caveat The authors say the findings need preregistered replication using behavioral outcomes, and the mediation analyses were exploratory.

    Answer in the thread
  4. Have you seen AI used this way where you study, work or live? Did it go the same way?

    Answer in the thread

The questions are the same on every record. The details under them are taken from this record as written.

What readers say