Emerging evidence
More
Marketers say AI boosts efficiency yet unsettles their expertise, in 20 interviews
Study title: Negotiating AI at work: motivational tensions and the redefinition of marketing expertise
- Evidence type
- Interviews or qualitative study
- Sample
- n = 20
- Sources
- 1 sourcePeer-reviewed
- Published
- 2 min read
- Truvace record
- TRV-2026-3093cite or check it
Study title: Negotiating AI at work: motivational tensions and the redefinition of marketing expertise
A qualitative study based on 20 in-depth interviews with marketing practitioners found that AI marketing tools simultaneously empower and destabilise the people using them. Practitioners described gains in efficiency, capability, strategic focus, confidence and creative possibilities.
Read the study abstract
Purpose Artificial Intelligence Marketing (AIM) tools are increasingly transforming how marketing work is performed. However, its impact on individual practitioners remains underexplored. This study aims to examine how marketing professionals experience and negotiate the contradictory motivational consequences of artificial intelligence (AI)-enabled work. Rather than treating AI as either empowering or threatening, the study explores how these effects coexist and how practitioners respond to them. Design/methodo…
49Gain side
How the two sides scoreClose call
46Problem side
The gain
In interviews with 20 marketing practitioners, participants said AI marketing tools improved their efficiency, capability, strategic focus, confidence and creative possibilities.
The problem
In the same 20 marketing practitioner interviews, participants described uncertainty about task ownership, professional identity, technological dependence and future relevance when working with AI marketing tools.
A fixed formula sets both scores from the evidence and its sources. Reader votes don’t move them.
What the scores mean
G is the gain side, out of 100. It goes up when the gain is specific, when it measurably helped people and when the sources behind it are strong.
P is the problem side, out of 100. It goes up when the problem is specific, when it measurably hurt people and when the sources behind it are strong.
In brief
The same practitioners also described uncertainty about who owns tasks, what their professional identity is, how dependent they are on technology and whether their skills will stay relevant. These effects were not experienced separately but together.
Practitioners responded by reframing their expertise, using AI selectively, keeping human control over consequential tasks and stressing distinctly human sources of professional value. The authors say motivation is continually reconstructed rather than a stable result of adopting AI.
Main points
- The study used 20 in-depth interviews with marketing practitioners in an exploratory qualitative design.
- Interpretation drew on Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs, Self-Determination Theory and the Job Characteristics Model, with themes developed through grounded-theory-informed coding.
- Reported benefits were efficiency, capability, strategic focus, confidence and creative possibilities.
- Reported destabilising effects were uncertainty over task ownership, professional identity, technological dependence and future relevance.
- Practitioners coped by selectively integrating AI and preserving human control over consequential tasks.
- The authors say AI shifts marketing expertise from task execution toward judgment, interpretation, contextual understanding and human–AI orchestration.
The full story
The researchers interviewed 20 marketing practitioners about how AI-enabled marketing tools affect their work. They used three theoretical lenses to guide interpretation while building themes from the interview data.
Rather than sorting effects into positive and negative, the authors report that empowerment and destabilisation coexist. Practitioners continually negotiate the tensions by reframing expertise, integrating AI selectively, keeping human control over consequential tasks and reaffirming human sources of value.
The authors recommend that organisations evaluate AI by how it changes employees' experience of expertise, ownership, autonomy and professional value. They also advise treating AI capability development as workforce transformation, giving employees agency over adoption and treating AI governance as part of the employee experience.
What this doesn’t fix
The design prioritises interpretive depth over statistical generalisability, did not analyse differences across career stages, and its cross-sectional design gives only a snapshot of how practitioners negotiate these tensions.
Sources
1 on file- European Journal of Marketingdoi:10.1108/ejm-11-2023-0827
Talk it over
The 20 marketing practitioners said AI improved their efficiency and confidence, and also described uncertainty about task ownership and future relevance. How would you weigh those gains against those uncertainties?
Marketers say AI boosts efficiency yet unsettles their expertise, in 20 interviewshttps://truvace.com/item/negotiating-ai-at-work-motivational-tensions-and-the-redefinition-of-marketing-e
The 20 marketing practitioners said AI improved their efficiency and confidence, and also described uncertainty about task ownership and future relevance. How would you weigh those gains against those uncertainties?
Answer in the threadThe authors chose 20 in-depth interviews over a statistical sample and did not compare career stages. How might a junior marketer's account differ from a senior one's, and what would that change?
Answer in the threadIf you were one of these practitioners keeping human control over consequential tasks, which tasks would you hold back from AI, and why?
Answer in the thread
If you have more time
The authors advise giving employees agency over adoption. What would that look like in a workplace you know, and who would decide where AI is used?
Answer in the threadWhat evidence, such as interviews repeated over time with the same practitioners, would show whether the tensions they described ease or deepen?
Answer in the thread
ace

What readers say