Moderate evidence
More
AI posture feedback helped 307 students learn Zhuang Daoyin better, a class-randomized trial shows
Study title: Effects of AI-mediated real-time feedback on motivation and motor skill learning in traditional ethnic sports education: testing self-determination theory mechanisms
- Evidence type
- Randomized controlled trial
- Sample
- n = 307
- Sources
- 1 sourcePeer-reviewed
- Published
- 2 min read
- Truvace record
- TRV-2026-2921cite or check it
Study title: Effects of AI-mediated real-time feedback on motivation and motor skill learning in traditional ethnic sports education: testing self-determination theory mechanisms
Twelve intact university classes in Guangxi, China (307 students) learned the traditional Zhuang Daoyin sequence for 12 weeks. Six classes practised with an RTMPose-based system that showed live posture feedback; six received teacher-led verbal correction. The AI group gained more in motor skill (d = 0.30), competence (d = 0.36), autonomy (d = 0.40) and learning interest (d = 0.38).
Read the study abstract
Introduction Traditional ethnic sports such as Zhuang Daoyin demand precise movement, yet conventional demonstration–imitation–verbal correction limits feedback timeliness and individualization. Artificial intelligence (AI) real-time posture feedback offers a scalable option, but most evaluations emphasize technical outcomes and overlook learning processes. Grounded in self-determination theory (SDT), this study tested whether and how AI real-time feedback improves motivation and motor skill by engaging basic ps…

The gain
In a 12-week cluster-randomized trial of 307 Chinese university students learning Zhuang Daoyin, the group using AI real-time posture feedback gained more in motor skill (d = 0.30) and competence (d = 0.36) than the group given teacher-led verbal correction.
In brief
The effect on motor skill ran through competence and then motivation quality: group predicted competence (β = 0.17), competence predicted relative autonomy (β = 0.34), and that predicted motor skill (β = 0.30). The direct path from AI feedback to skill was not significant (p = 0.097), which the authors read as full mediation.
Relatedness did not change (p = 0.974), which the authors interpret as showing the tool works through feedback rather than general enthusiasm. They recommend that teachers keep providing relational support alongside AI feedback. Effects on the composite motivation index were less consistent across analyses.
Main points
- Twelve intact classes were randomly allocated by computer-generated sequence: 6 to AI feedback and 6 to teacher feedback, with 152 control and 155 AI students analysed.
- Both groups had the same 90-minute weekly sessions, and the only difference was feedback during the 45-minute practice phase. Attendance was 94.2% (AI) versus 94.6% (control).
- The AI system used a webcam and RTMPose to detect 133 body keypoints with about 120 ms latency, compared against 28 expert-validated templates, and showed a skeleton overlay and colour-coded heatmap.
- Motor skill was rated from video by two blinded instructors, with inter-rater reliability of 0.94 at post-test.
- Adjusted post-test motor skill means were 3.054 for AI versus 2.914 for control (ANCOVA p = 0.010); the mixed-model group-by-time interaction for skill was b = 0.225 (p = 0.006).
- Course satisfaction, concentration and vitality did not differ significantly between groups, and the total effect of AI feedback on satisfaction was not significant (p = 0.296).
- The structural model explained 10.0% of the variance in motor skill.
The full story
Zhuang Daoyin is a traditional Zhuang ethnic practice with complex movement patterns, usually taught by demonstration, imitation and verbal correction in which one teacher watches many students. The researchers argue this limits how timely and individual the feedback is, and tested whether live AI feedback could help while also examining students' psychological experience.
Participants were second-year undergraduates at a university of Chinese medicine, with no prior training, who attended a public PE elective. In the AI condition, instructors circulated only for safety and gave no technical corrections, so the system was the sole source of correction. Control students received scripted verbal feedback from the same three instructors, each teaching two AI and two control classes.
Group differences were tested with mixed models and ANCOVAs, and mediation with structural equation modeling. Class-level intraclass correlations were 0.03 or lower. Sensitivity analyses, including per-protocol and cluster-robust checks, left the core mediation findings directionally unchanged.
The composite relative autonomy index favoured the AI group in the ANCOVA (p = 0.042) but not in the mixed-model interaction (p = 0.209), so the effect on overall motivation was smaller and less robust than that on competence and skill.
Sources
1 on file- Frontiers in Psychologydoi:10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1958348
Talk it over
Twelve intact classes in Guangxi, China were randomized, six to AI feedback and six to teacher feedback. What does assigning whole classes rather than individual students let this trial show, and what might it hide?
AI posture feedback helped 307 students learn Zhuang Daoyin better, a class-randomized trial showshttps://truvace.com/item/effects-of-ai-mediated-real-time-feedback-on-motivation-and-motor-skill-learning
Twelve intact classes in Guangxi, China were randomized, six to AI feedback and six to teacher feedback. What does assigning whole classes rather than individual students let this trial show, and what might it hide?
Answer in the threadThe AI group gained more in motor skill (d = 0.30) and competence (d = 0.36), yet relatedness did not change. How would you weigh those gains against what the students did not get from instructors who gave no technical corrections?
Answer in the threadThe composite relative autonomy index favoured the AI group in one analysis (p = 0.042) but not in another (p = 0.209). What further result would convince you the AI feedback changes motivation overall?
Answer in the thread
If you have more time
The students were second-year undergraduates at a university of Chinese medicine with no prior training. Who else might learn Zhuang Daoyin, and how could that change the results?
Answer in the threadThe authors recommend teachers keep giving relational support alongside AI feedback. What would a trial of that combination need to compare?
Answer in the thread
ace
What readers say