Moderate evidence
More
Employees who use GenAI to build ideas are more creative; those who use it to replace effort are less, a study finds
Study title: Augmentation or automation? A dual-path model of GenAI usage motivations and employee creativity
- Evidence type
- Controlled or validated comparison
- Sources
- 1 sourcePeer-reviewed
- Published
- 2 min read
- Truvace record
- TRV-2026-2900cite or check it
Study title: Augmentation or automation? A dual-path model of GenAI usage motivations and employee creativity
A study combining a multi-wave, multi-source field survey with a scenario-based experiment found that the reason employees use generative AI matters for their creativity. Those motivated to augment their own work showed higher creativity, while those motivated to automate it showed lower creativity.
Read the study abstract
Purpose Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) can both enhance and constrain employee creativity, yet the mechanisms underlying these divergent effects remain unclear. This study examines how augmentation and automation motivations for GenAI usage shape employee creativity through distinct knowledge-processing mechanisms. Design/methodology/approach Drawing on dual-process theory and self-regulation theory, we distinguish augmentation and automation motivations for GenAI usage and propose distinct cognitive…

The gain
A multi-wave, multi-source field survey and scenario experiment found that employees who used generative AI to augment their own thinking were more creative, through better integration of knowledge.
In brief
The researchers trace the two effects to different mental mechanisms. Augmentation works through knowledge integration, while automation works through knowledge dependence. Conscientiousness amplified the benefit of augmentation and dampened the harm from automation.
The work shifts the question from how much employees use GenAI to why they use it. The authors recommend that organisations encourage employees to use GenAI to generate and develop ideas rather than replace their own judgment.
Main points
- The study separates two motivations for using generative AI: augmentation and automation.
- Augmentation motivation was positively linked to employee creativity via knowledge integration.
- Automation motivation was negatively linked to creativity via knowledge dependence.
- Conscientiousness strengthened the positive effect of augmentation and weakened the negative effect of automation.
- Evidence comes from a multi-wave, multi-source field survey and a scenario-based experiment.
- The authors suggest training employees to critically assess AI-generated suggestions and combine them with their own knowledge.
The full story
The research draws on dual-process theory and self-regulation theory to propose that augmentation and automation motivations lead to creativity through different knowledge-processing routes. Hypotheses were tested with a multi-wave, multi-source field survey and a scenario-based experiment.
Results show opposite indirect effects. Knowledge integration carries the positive effect of augmentation, while knowledge dependence carries the negative effect of automation. Conscientiousness moderated both paths, boosting the first and reducing the second.
For employers, the authors advise encouraging staff to use GenAI to generate and develop ideas rather than replace their own judgment, and offering training in critically assessing AI suggestions. They frame the contribution as moving attention from how much employees use GenAI to why they use it.
Sources
1 on file- Internet Researchdoi:10.1108/intr-07-2025-1110
Talk it over
Employees who used generative AI to augment their thinking were more creative, and those who used it to automate were less. Which of these two motivations would you expect in your own use of AI, and why?
Employees who use GenAI to build ideas are more creative; those who use it to replace effort are less, a study findshttps://truvace.com/item/augmentation-or-automation-a-dual-path-model-of-genai-usage-motivations-and-empl
Employees who used generative AI to augment their thinking were more creative, and those who used it to automate were less. Which of these two motivations would you expect in your own use of AI, and why?
Answer in the threadThe creativity findings rest on a multi-wave, multi-source field survey and a scenario-based experiment, where people react to described situations. How far could a scenario tell us what employees actually do with generative AI at work?
Answer in the threadThe authors note that augmentation and automation motivations may coexist and vary across tasks. Which tasks or workers might be missing from the picture, and how could that change the result?
Answer in the thread
If you have more time
The authors suggest training employees to critically assess AI-generated suggestions. What would a training session like that cover, and how would you measure whether it worked?
Answer in the threadConscientiousness strengthened the benefit of augmentation and weakened the harm from automation. How might that play out on a team you know, and who would you want to ask?
Answer in the thread
ace
What readers say