Emerging evidence
More
Seventeen GP trainees in Germany said AI speeds decisions but risks deskilling
Study title: Artificial intelligence and clinical reasoning - a qualitative study with general practice trainees in Germany
- Evidence type
- Interviews or qualitative study
- Sample
- n = 17
- Sources
- 1 sourcePeer-reviewed
- Published
- 2 min read
- Truvace record
- TRV-2026-2917cite or check it
Study title: Artificial intelligence and clinical reasoning - a qualitative study with general practice trainees in Germany
Researchers in Germany interviewed 17 general practice trainees about how they use large language models in clinical reasoning. Trainees described AI as a tool that augments and accelerates clinical decision-making and gives them easier access to medical knowledge.
Read the study abstract
Abstract Background General practitioners face high complexity in clinical decision-making. Large language models (LLMs) may support clinical reasoning, but their impact on decision-making processes and postgraduate medical training remains unclear. This qualitative study aims to explore General Practice (GP) trainee’s use of LLMs in clinical reasoning and their educational needs. Materials and methods GP trainees were recruited and interviewed with semi-structured interview-guide. Interviews were transcribed ve…

50Gain side
How the two sides scoreClose call
52Problem side
The gain
In interviews with 17 GP trainees in Germany, participants said AI helped augment and accelerate clinical decision-making and improved access to medical knowledge.
The problem
In interviews with 17 GP trainees in Germany, participants identified overreliance on AI-generated information and deskilling as risks, and reported no structured AI education in their training.
A fixed formula sets both scores from the evidence and its sources. Reader votes don’t move them.
What the scores mean
G is the gain side, out of 100. It goes up when the gain is specific, when it measurably helped people and when the sources behind it are strong.
P is the problem side, out of 100. It goes up when the problem is specific, when it measurably hurt people and when the sources behind it are strong.
In brief
The same trainees named risks: overreliance on AI-generated information and possible effects on how clinical expertise develops, including deskilling. They also said they had received no structured AI education and wanted it built into postgraduate training.
The authors conclude that AI is already part of clinical practice among GP trainees. They argue that postgraduate GP training should teach critical appraisal, ethical responsibility and appropriate integration of AI into decision-making.
Main points
- Seventeen GP trainees were interviewed with a semi-structured guide; interviews averaged 38 minutes (range 21 to 63) and were transcribed verbatim and analysed qualitatively.
- Trainees saw AI as a way to augment and accelerate clinical decision-making.
- Participants said AI can complement clinical reasoning and improve access to medical knowledge.
- Trainees identified overreliance on AI-generated information and deskilling as potential risks to developing clinical expertise.
- Participants reported a lack of structured AI education and called for it in postgraduate training.
The full story
The study recruited GP trainees in Germany and used semi-structured interviews to explore how they use large language models in clinical reasoning and what education they need. Seventeen trainees took part, with interviews lasting 21 to 63 minutes.
Participants mainly viewed AI as a supportive tool that complements clinical reasoning. At the same time they flagged overreliance on AI-generated information and possible effects on the development of clinical expertise.
From these findings the authors recommend that postgraduate GP training cover AI competencies, including critical appraisal, ethical responsibility and appropriate integration of AI into clinical decision-making, so that use is responsible, reflective and patient-centred.
Sources
1 on file- BMC Medical Educationdoi:10.1186/s12909-026-10736-3
Talk it over
The 17 GP trainees said AI speeds clinical decisions and widens access to medical knowledge, yet they also named overreliance and deskilling. How would you weigh the speed against the risk to how their expertise develops?
Seventeen GP trainees in Germany said AI speeds decisions but risks deskillinghttps://truvace.com/item/artificial-intelligence-and-clinical-reasoning-a-qualitative-study-with-general-
The 17 GP trainees said AI speeds clinical decisions and widens access to medical knowledge, yet they also named overreliance and deskilling. How would you weigh the speed against the risk to how their expertise develops?
Answer in the threadThe study rests on interviews averaging 38 minutes with 17 trainees in Germany, describing their own use of large language models. What can trainees' own accounts tell us about whether skills are actually wearing away?
Answer in the threadThe trainees said they had received no structured AI education and wanted it in postgraduate training. Who should decide what that teaching covers, and which of critical appraisal, ethical responsibility or appropriate integration should come first?
Answer in the thread
If you have more time
Ask a trainee or doctor you know how they check an AI answer against their own reasoning. How does that compare with the critical appraisal the authors recommend?
Answer in the threadWhat kind of study could show whether overreliance on AI-generated information changes trainees' clinical expertise over time, rather than only what they say about it?
Answer in the thread
ace
What readers say