62/100

Moderate evidence

Cite
More
EmailLinkedInX

Allegheny Health Network, Highmark Health Used AI Documentation Tool Without Consent, Class Action Suit Claims

Evidence type
Regulatory or legal action
Sources
1 sourceJournalism
Published
2 min read

A proposed class action lawsuit alleges that Allegheny Health Network and parent company Highmark Health have violated a Pennsylvania privacy law by using an AI-powered ambient recording tool to document conversations between patients and t…

The problem

A proposed class action alleges Allegheny Health Network and Highmark Health used Abridge's AI tool to record patient-doctor conversations in Pennsylvania without informed consent, with some patients told nothing and the recordings allegedly used to train Abridge's models.

In brief

A proposed class action filed against Allegheny Health Network and its parent, Highmark Health, alleges they broke the Pennsylvania Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Control Act and doctor-patient confidentiality. The 58-page complaint says they deployed Abridge's AI clinical documentation tool in exam rooms without informed consent from patients.

According to the complaint, once a clinician activates the tool it passively captures unfiltered conversations, sends them to Abridge's servers and turns them into a clinical note. The suit says Abridge also uses the recordings to train and improve its AI models, and that some patients were told only that an AI tool would be used, while others were told nothing.

The suit calls the practice "deliberate and systemic" and argues that clear disclosure would have led many patients to refuse. These are allegations in a complaint; no ruling or finding has been reported, and the proposed class covers patients seen at Allegheny Health Network-affiliated Pennsylvania facilities where Abridge was activated.

Main points

  1. The 58-page complaint alleges violations of the Pennsylvania Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Control Act and of doctor-patient confidentiality.
  2. The tool at issue is Abridge AI's ambient clinical documentation system, which is activated by a clinician and sends conversations to Abridge's servers to be turned into clinical notes.
  3. The suit alleges Abridge uses recordings to train and improve its AI models, creating a "corpus" of confidential medical information.
  4. Some patients were allegedly told only that an AI tool would be used, and others were told nothing at all.
  5. The defendants allegedly adopted the tool to lighten clinicians' note-taking, speed prior authorization for insurance members and capture billing information.
  6. The proposed class covers anyone who attended an appointment at a Pennsylvania Allegheny Health Network facility where Abridge was activated, from deployment until class certification.

The full story

The complaint says Allegheny Health Network and Highmark Health deployed Abridge's clinical documentation tool in exam rooms and other clinical settings. It argues they failed to obtain informed consent before recording private patient-provider conversations, in breach of Pennsylvania's wiretapping law and doctor-patient confidentiality.

On how the tool works, the filing says that once a clinician activates it, it passively records the conversation, transmits it to Abridge's servers and processes it into a clinical note. It adds that Abridge also uses the recordings to train and improve its models, and that patients were not given adequate notice of this commercial use.

The plaintiffs say the practice was "deliberate and systemic" and deprived patients of the confidential services they paid for. They argue that silence let the defendants deploy the technology without the refusals honest disclosure would have invited. The defendants allegedly adopted the tool to ease note-taking, speed prior authorization and capture billing information.

The proposed class includes all individuals who, between the date of deployment and class certification, attended an appointment at a Pennsylvania facility operated by or affiliated with Allegheny Health Network where Abridge was activated to record, transcribe or process the encounter.

Sources

1 on file
  1. classaction.orgclassaction.org
    Journalism2026-11-10

Talk it over

Three questions to start on, two more if you have time
Some patients at Allegheny Health Network facilities were allegedly told only that an AI tool would be used, and others were told nothing. If you were one of those patients, what would you want to hear before the recording began?

Start with a question

Allegheny Health Network, Highmark Health Used AI Documentation Tool Without Consent, Class Action Suit Claimshttps://truvace.com/item/allegheny-health-network-highmark-health-used-ai-documentation-tool-without-cons

  1. Some patients at Allegheny Health Network facilities were allegedly told only that an AI tool would be used, and others were told nothing. If you were one of those patients, what would you want to hear before the recording began?

    Answer in the thread
  2. The defendants allegedly adopted Abridge's tool to lighten note-taking, speed prior authorization and capture billing information. How would you weigh those aims against the claim that recordings were also used to train Abridge's models?

    Answer in the thread
  3. This is a proposed class action, and the class has not been certified and no court has ruled. What finding or document would settle whether patients gave informed consent?

    Answer in the thread
If you have more time
  • Find out how a clinic or hospital you know tells patients when a conversation is recorded or processed by software. What does it say, and who gives that notice?

    Answer in the thread
  • The complaint says clear disclosure would have led many patients to refuse. What evidence, such as patient surveys or refusal rates, could test that claim?

    Answer in the thread

What readers say